Let there be light, if only to light up our real voyage through time.

On the Nimble Theory Blog I read that nothing can travel faster than the speed of light. I’m also reminded by the blogger of Brian Greene’s statement (from The Fabric of the Cosmos, p.49) that “the combined speed of any object’s motion through space and it’s motion though time is always precisely equal to the speed of light.”

I’m familiar with the fact that time slows down the closer you get to the speed of light. You all remember the story of the one twin going off to Alpha Centauri at something like light speed and coming back after 80,000 years having only aged 3 months since he left.

I read Greene’s words to mean that all of us, and you too, everything, your computer, the meal you’re about to eat, the books in your library, the tools in your shop, everything there is, everything all about you is traveling at the speed of light.

Why is this so? Because everything is traveling through something called, since Einstein, spacetime, consisting of (at least) three spatial dimensions plus time. It is the total movement through space and time that will always equal the speed of light —the result being that when you increase your speed through space you decrease your speed through time, and vice versa, not being able to ever reach a combined spacetime speed faster than light.

Light has a special place in all this. Light moves only through space and at light speed. There is no movement through time, with the result being that every photon that has ever “lived” is ageless. The universe ages, light does not.

Now if you’re still with me, let me share with you the following discussion, much of this I’ve taken from Andrew Fraknoi’s blog, The Universe in the Classroom. To begin Fraknoi asks how fast are you moving when you are sitting still?

For when we are sitting still, much of the time for most of us, as I am now, at my computer, and when I’m not on a fast train taking me to Aix en Provence, or on a cruise ship heading for Spain from Fort Lauderdale, or on a catamaran doing 9 knots between Les Marquesas and Hawaii, I am still moving, and moving much more and much faster than in any one of the situations I mention.

For while sitting, or while sailing or doing anything else, we are fully a part of the following motions:

1. With the earth that once a day turns on its axis, moving at close to 1000 miles per hour at a point near the equator, and slowing down somewhat as you move north.

2. With the earth again as it revolves around the Sun. We are approximately 93 million miles from the Sun, and at that distance it takes us one year to make the full circle, our path being close to 600 million miles, which means an orbital speed of 66,000 miles per hour, a speed that would take you from San Francisco to Washington DC in 3 minutes.

3. With the members of our local group including the Sun in the Milky Way Galaxy, a kind of “milling about” speed, but still moving at 43,000 mph, roughly in the direction of the bright star Vega in the constellation of Lyra.

4. And we move along with the entire Milky Way Galaxy itself as it spins, with us in it, like an enormous pinwheel. Now it takes our Sun, and therefore us along with it, approximately 225 million years to make the trip around our Galaxy. This is the “galactic year.” And since the Sun and the Earth first formed about 20 galactic years have passed, meaning that we have been around the Galaxy 20 times. On the other hand, throughout all of recorded human history, we have barely moved along this path.

How fast do we have to move to make it around the Milky Way in one galactic year? It’s a huge circle, and the speed with which the Sun has to move is an astounding 483,000 miles per hour and the earth, anchored to the Sun by gravity, follows along at that same fantastic speed.

5. Finally we are moving with the entire Galaxy through empty space. To understand this we will need to bring into our discussion the Big Bang, that enormous explosion that marked the beginning of space, time, and everything else, the entire universe.

As the early universe grew it expanded, that which was, and still is, a kind of stretching of space itself. And as space stretches, creating more distance between the galaxies, these are seen to be moving apart. How fast is our Milky Way Galaxy expanding? This speed turns out to be an astounding 1.3 million miles per hour!

Now all these motions, all motions that we are part of even while sitting in our favorite chair, — rotating on the earth’s axis (1000 mph), about the sun (66,000 mph), within our galaxy (43,000 mph), following the path of the galactic year (483,000 mph), and being a part of the expansion or stretching of the universe (1.3 million mph) — all these motions together do not come even close (much less than 2 million mph given the multiple directions of the motions) to the speed of light  which is tops at 670 million miles per hour.

So, what can we now say about Greene’s statement, that the combined speed of any object’s motion through space and it’s motion though time is always precisely equal to the speed of light?

Well it’s clear that our motion, while alive on this earth, is nearly 100% (perhaps 99.9) motion through time. We are time creatures. And it’s true that time for us is much more important than space.

While as Green points out we may be traveling at light speed, nearly all of this movement consists in our growing old, and, if you will have it that way, at the speed of light.

2 thoughts on “Let there be light, if only to light up our real voyage through time.”

  1. Philip:

    Great post and certainly very interesting.

    As for nothing traveling faster than the speed of light – this is based on our current understanding of science.

    Will this still be true when our science has advanced for another 10,000 years? Maybe yes – maybe no. If true perhaps one can travel faster than light in another dimension. If you can bend space time you may not be going faster than light as you are cheating, but you still have traveled to a point faster than light can.

    Perhaps if really advanced one can travel at the speed of thought – instantly arrive where one wants.

    I am not trying to introduce science fiction to the topic rather trying to emphasize that what we now know to be true isn’t necessarily the case.

    Both Greene and Kaku have written books on string theory and about additional dimensions. What happens to light in the 4th spatial dimension and above?

    If light only moves through space and not time then why does light change over time? I’m not talking about change between summer and winter as this is related to earth angle rather stars die out. If light is always there why does this happen?

    Light is emitted by the sun, but in a few billion years it won’t.

    You’ve mention space and time. What about gravity and how this affects both? Maybe light is a wave resulting from something occurring in the 4th spatial dimension or higher.

    Very interesting thoughts and hard to argue with a theoretical physicist.

    I would say time doesn’t exist other than in the lower dimensions and at higher dimensions everything happens all at once.

    I think your argument is a bit sophist in nature and while fun unclear if entirely accurate. LOL

    If we are traveling at light speed then if I am following you on I-75 at the same speed at night then you wouldn’t mind if I put my high beams on as the light would never reach you and if it did the light would be going faster than light speed.

    It’s like the argument if a tree falls in the woods and no one is there to hear it does it make a noise?

    Of course it does. The tree falling creates a shock wave and noise is perception of this. Given that the forest is filled with animals their ear drums will pick up the shock wave.

    Let me know your thoughts.

    I would like to know where you got the info that the Milky Way is expanding at 1.3 million miles per hour as I saw a program last night that disagrees with this.

    As per the big bang – is this accurate? Galaxies at the edge of the visible universe seem to be expanding superluminally.

    My point again is we just don’t know enough about the physics of the universe.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s